does what it is supposed to. nice and burly, but simple. Really durable, and super bright orange! Can't lose it. Bought this after a pair of pants tore in my bag. I have heard a lot of reviews that these bags were too small for their crampons, not sure what their issue was. I put my wife's grivel g12's and my BD cyborgs in here, and both with with a little extra room.
it's a crampon bag, i'm sure you can't go wrong with any of the other options, but this is a good bag.