reviewsfacebooklogincreate account
Staying Safe With 3-Antenna Avalanche Beacons
If caught and buried in an avalanche, you have a 50-percent chance of surviving. Out of those on the wrong side of chance, 25-percent die from trauma and the other 75-percent die from suffocation. Wearing an avalanche beacon increases your odds of surviving an avalanche burial, if you and your partner each have a good beacon and know how to use the technology properly. The latest step in beacon technology, the addition of a third antenna, also will help you and your partner avoid that 37.5-percent chance of suffocation.

How Beacons Work
Avalanche beacons are a type of radio transceiver that send and receive signals. They are the size of a small PB&J sandwich, typically weigh 10-12 ounces, and have a weatherproof, hard exterior designed for tough winter conditions.

“Beacons consist of antennas and software. They crunch the numbers and give you info that is useful,” said Ethan Greene, director of the Colorado Avalanche Information Center located in Boulder. Inside modern avalanche beacons are two or three internal antennas. When traveling in the snowy mountains you set the beacon to “transmit” and it sends a 457 kHz signal from one antenna. When a victim is buried, rescuers switch their beacon to “search” and the searching beacon receives signals on all antennas.

First generation beacons, such as the Ortovox F1, used a single antenna that sent out an analog (real-time, unprocessed) signal. Rescuers received this signal as an audible signal – searches were done by moving toward the loudest signal.

In 1997, the manufacturer Backcountry Access introduced the first dual antenna beacon: the Tracker DTS, which calculated a direction to the transmitting beacon through internal software. Many praised the Tracker’s simplicity, saying you could hand the Tracker to an untrained user, tell them to follow the arrow, and they could find a victim. Some professionals discredited the Tracker DTS by saying its tendency for dead spots – meaning when the beacon shows no reading because of crossed signals – was too high for reliability. Despite these problems, almost all beacon manufacturers began using dual antenna technology.

Three Antenna Beacons
The most recent development in beacon technology is the addition of a third antenna. “Three antennas give you more resolution because they have the X, Y, and Z directions,” said Greene. Many models currently have a third antenna: Barryvox Pulse, Pieps DSP, Ortovox Patroller (formerly X1), D3, and S1.

The main purpose of the third antenna is to eliminate spikes in the fine search phase. A spike is when your beacon leads you to the strongest signal that is near, but not directly above, the victim. “The third antenna has nothing to do with multiple burials or max range,” explained Bruce Edgerly, director of Backcountry Access. “It’s only about smoothing out the pinpointing process so that you don’t have any spikes, or what people used to call nulls. A null is when an analog beacon loses the sound because the signal is weak in that direction.”

The transmitting antenna in a beacon sends out a signal shaped like an apple core. “The reason we get spiked signals is because the receiving beacon is perpendicular to the transmitting beacon’s electromagnetic field at some point on the way in,” Edgerly said. “The third antenna is able to align with the perpendicular part of the field so we don’t have a weak signal. That’s the concept behind a third antenna.”

“The key point to remember is that a third antenna and marking/masking feature on some beacons are not linked,” said Jonathan Shefftz, an AIARE* instructor, who has a detailed beacon review on WildSnow.com. Marking, also known as masking, is a feature on some newer beacons for multiple burial situations that allows the transmitting beacon’s signal to be blocked out once a probe strike has been made, allowing searchers to move onto other victims.

Beacons are not avalanche deflectors. If you’re heading into the snowy backcountry with a new partner, ask them: “When was the last time you practiced with your beacon?” If they say less than three months, stop right then and practice. Even if beacons become an iPhone app, complete with distance, depth, and pulse display of multiple victims, you'll have to keep practicing.

*American Institute for Avalanche Research and Education

Liked it? Share it! Bookmark and Share
Author
Joe Stock works as a writer, photographer and a fully-certified IFMGA mountain guide based in Anchorage. Joe is sponsored by Osprey, G3, Hilleberg, Scarpa, Dermatone, Wigwam, Smith, and Feathered Friends.
Stay in the Loop
New articles, every week.
RSSTwitterFacebook
Comments
Add a comment

Cred: 77
Comment by abelrevenge
2009-10-09
You forgot to mention the PIEPS DSP which is a 3 antenna beacon, was released 6 years ago and in my experience has amazing range and simplicity of use.

Cred: 47
Comment by joestock
2009-10-12
Hi Abelrevenge,

You're right. I checked with Jonathan Shefftz and he says "Many models currently have a third antenna: Barryvox Pulse, Pieps DSP, Ortovox Patroller (formerly X1), D3, and S1. Also, BCA plans to introduce the Tracker 2, a three-antenna version of its original Tracker. (The French company ARVA also has three-antenna models -- Evo3, A.D.vanced, Link -- but has very limited distributed in North America.)"

Thanks,

Joe
Comment by
2009-10-12
Very helpful article overall, and clears up some regrettably commonplace misconceptions on what function a third antenna performs (and also what it doesnt do).

But two clarifications:
"First generation beacons, such as the Ortovox F1, used a single antenna that sent out an analog (real-time, unprocessed) signal. Rescuers received this signal as an audible signal searches were done by moving toward the loudest signal."
- All beacons use a single antenna to transmit, and all beacons send out the same type of signal (although the spec for its timing and frequency is surprisingly wide). The difference among beacons is in receiving/searching, not transmitting. (Well, except for the additional frequency the Barryvox Pulse uses for vitals transmission, but thats an ancillary function.)

"Some professionals discredited the Tracker DTS by saying its tendency for dead spots meaning when the beacon shows no reading because of crossed signals was too high for reliability."
- I don't remember this, since even single-antenna beacons at the time of the Trackers debut also suffered from nulls and spikes. What I do remember were critiques of the Trackers maximum receive as significantly shorter than traditional single-antenna beacons (and also now of some other multiple-antenna models that have managed to expand the search range), and that the digitized "beeps" and directional signals could be confusing in a multiple-burial search (which some other multiple-antenna models have since addressed with marking/flagging functions).
- Just how much range matters though, and just how frequently multiple burials are encountered, are both the subject of considerable debate. For additional reading on the latter topic, see, for example: www.americanavalancheasso ciation.org/tar/TAR27_2_L oRes.pdf

Cred: 47
Comment by joestock
2009-10-13
Right on Jonathan! Thanks!

Please login or create a new account to add a comment.
Hungry for more?
View all articles
Want to write for Gear Talk?
Spadout is on the prowl for creative gearheads who know how to write. Interested? Check out the writer's guidelines.
Contact Us | About Us | Brands © 2011 Spadout Inc